Diptera.info :: Miscellaneous :: General queries
Who is here? 1 guest(s)
 UK ID Book?
|
|
| Denis |
Posted on 12-12-2005 11:19
|
|
Member Location: Wye Valley near Chepstow, UK Posts: 3 Joined: 12.12.05 |
Does anyone have a suggested UK key/guidebook/etc which would at least enable me to get to genus level in Britain? I work for the RSPB and am always coming across things I'd like to ID - I sometimes take pictures too so could post stuff here but I'd like to at least have a go at working them out myself first. Best Wishes Denis Jackson |
 |
|
| Robert Nash |
Posted on 12-12-2005 18:09
|
|
Member Location: Ulster Museum, Belfast, Ireland Posts: 288 Joined: 11.11.05 |
Do you have the Unwin Aidgap Key to Families? This is a very useful, comparatively easy, guide but out of print. I can post a xerox, or possibly scan it. Genus is more difficult. Which families are you most interested in? If you're beginning the badly out of date  but relatively easy to use Faune de France keys are a good start. After that it's the RESL handbooks, Fauna Entomologica Scandinavica , and some good monographs. Get back in touch if I can help furtherPrivate Messages perhaps (i'll need your address) Robert Nash in Belfast, Ireland |
|
|
|
| Kahis |
Posted on 12-12-2005 22:15
|
 Member Location: Helsinki, Finland Posts: 1999 Joined: 02.09.04 |
Hi. Possibly the best genus-level keys I've seen are in the Manual of Nearctic diptera (three volumes). It's definitely not cheap (but still much cheaper than the corresponding Palearctic magnus opus). While the nearctic keys are for North American fauna, the differences at genus level are small especially from us N/NW. At least vol. 1 is out of print. If you can afford it, then Papp, L. & Darvas, B. (eds.) Contributions to a Manual of Palearctic Diptera is excellent if a bit overwhelming at times. It covers most but not all families (among the missing families is my favourite, Dolichopodidae ). Bei-Bienko (ed): Keys to the insects of the European part of the USSR. V. Diptera and Siphonaptera has genus- and species-level keys for (nominally) all Diptera recorded from (what was) European USSR. It is already quite old - originally published in 1969 - and the english translation is also out of print I'm not aware of any other works with keys for most European dipteran genera. Kahis |
|
|
|
| Kahis |
Posted on 12-12-2005 22:21
|
|
Member Location: Helsinki, Finland Posts: 1999 Joined: 02.09.04 |
For occasional specimens I recommend sorting them to family level and then asking for help if you can't find id. guides down to species level  Very few if any dipterists are capable of sorting *all* diptera to genus level.
Kahis |
|
|
|
| Paul Beuk |
Posted on 13-12-2005 11:16
|
 Super Administrator Location: Netherlands Posts: 19229 Joined: 11.05.04 |
To put it simply, the requested work(s) do not exist. The above mentioned works have their uses and disadvantages. For example: Manual of Nearctic Diptera: Well composed and well illustrated. Definitely very useful but it should be noted that: a. Systematics are dealt with differently then here in Europe (tipuloid and empidiod families); b. Though for some families the generic composition of the North American and European faunas are quite similar, for others there are marked differences. With a somewhat lower diversity in Britain compared to mainland Europe, the differences are probably less than the ones we experience on the continent; c: nomenclature is already becoming outdated for some families. Contributions to a Manual of Palaearctic Diptera: Generally well composed but the print is definitely lesser quality. The advantage is that the composition of families is (completely) compatible with that of Britain, but unfortunately, not all families have yet been included. Keys to the insects of the European part of the USSR: Definitely useful in general terms (I still use it myself, too) but with the warning that nomenclature is hopelessly outdated, not for every family the keys are reliable, and that the generic composition may not always correspond with the British one. I agree with Robert Nash that Fauna Entomologica Scandinavica will often provide excellent keys, but again, these may not include some of the British genera. One entry to literature from the family level is provided in the book by Oosterbroek et al. (2005). Not yet published in English but it may be worth your while. Paul - - - - Paul Beuk on https://diptera.info |
|
|
|
| Jump to Forum: |
