Gallery Links
Users Online
· Guests Online: 8

· Members Online: 1
binturong

· Total Members: 4,542
· Newest Member: Wakolbe
Forum Threads
Theme Switcher
Switch to:
Last Seen Users
· binturongOnline
· Tony Irwin00:21:01
· libor00:27:49
· basileus00:33:48
· Bugduche00:46:57
· Mark-uk00:56:54
· Jan Maca01:29:39
· almaviva01:34:56
· Nikita Vikhrev01:47:22
· Zeegers01:48:22
Latest Photo Additions
View Thread
Diptera.info :: Identification queries :: Diptera (adults)
Who is here? 1 guest(s)
 Print Thread
Sarcophaga variegata
Rui Andrade
#1 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 16:34
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

Hi,

Could this be Sarcophaga carnaria? Comparing the plates in Richet et al. (2011) I find it more similar to S. variegata, but looking at these photos by Chris Raper it looks similar to S. carnaria:
http://chrisraper...5130_o.jpg

What do you think?

location: Porto (Portugal)
date: 27/09/2019
Rui Andrade attached the following image:


[132.07Kb]
Edited by Rui Andrade on 24-10-2019 22:28
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
Rui Andrade
#2 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 16:34
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

.
Rui Andrade attached the following image:


[204.88Kb]
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
Rui Andrade
#3 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 16:34
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

.
Rui Andrade attached the following image:


[106.2Kb]
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
Rui Andrade
#4 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 16:35
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

.
Rui Andrade attached the following image:


[105.81Kb]
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
Rui Andrade
#5 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 16:35
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

.
Rui Andrade attached the following image:


[152.94Kb]
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
PhilC
#6 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 21:11
User Avatar

Member

Location: Essex, UK
Posts: 52
Joined: 17.12.13

The last picture is S. variegata, and it looks to me just like Chris's photo of that species so I am rather confused by what you say.
 
Rui Andrade
#7 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 22:44
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

Thank you Phil. In Chris's photo of S. variegata the vesica looks very narrow to me. Also the shape of the ventral plate of my specimen seems to best match the one of S. carnaria. But this is the first time I'm trying to interpret the genitalia of a Sarcophaga so I have no experience at all. S. carnaria is not known from Iberia, so S. variegata also makes more sense from a distribution point of view.
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
johnes81
#8 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 22:47
User Avatar

Member

Location: Berlin, Germany
Posts: 1978
Joined: 15.10.16

Hello Rui,

it is certainly not carnaria simply because of the shape and angle of the vesica.

I don't need anyone's photos to judge either species because i've dissected the genitalia of both. I have also properly cleared the genitalia for better viewing, thus, i don't recommend using those photos for your determinations. I will attach a photo of properly cleared genitalia of S. carnaria for reference.

S. variegata will have a flap covering the distiphallus . I see a dark structure twisted toward the end of the distiphallus and the vesica match variegata much better than carnaria.

Best wishes,
John
johnes81 attached the following image:


[35.89Kb]
John and Nini. Naturalists not experts.
 
johnes81
#9 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 22:51
User Avatar

Member

Location: Berlin, Germany
Posts: 1978
Joined: 15.10.16

ps i own a copy of Sarcophagidae of Fennoscandia and Denmark by Dr. Pape. His work is nonpareil in my opinion and he is a very nice man. I have much respect for Dr. Pape and also Dr. Rognes. I recommend using the material of Dr. Pape for determinations.

Best wishes,
John
John and Nini. Naturalists not experts.
 
Rui Andrade
#10 Print Post
Posted on 18-10-2019 23:19
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

Hi John,

Thank you very much for the photo of the genitalia of S. carnaria. I think I was too focused on the shape of the vesica rather than its orientation and the general shape of distiphallus. Now I see that, although the vesica on Chris's photo of S. variegata seems very narrow, the rest of the distiphallus is indeed very similar to my specimen.
I also have a copy of Sarcophagidae of Fennoscandia and Denmark but forgot to have a look because, for the fauna of Portugal, it makes more sense to use Richet et al. But now I'll have a look at that one too. Smile

Thank you both very much!
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
johnes81
#11 Print Post
Posted on 19-10-2019 10:15
User Avatar

Member

Location: Berlin, Germany
Posts: 1978
Joined: 15.10.16

Hello Rui,

I stick with the work of Dr. Pape when he has material about the species. Otherwise, i fall back to Spixiana.

I have taken a few moments to outline my own dissections using a computer mouse. My hand is too shaky to be precise when using a computer mouse. I think that the illustration is good enough for the purpose of emphasizing the teachings of Dr. Pape. I am not able to convey my knowledge to you, so a good teacher will be able to describe what i am hoping is obvious in my illustrations.

I will attach a jpeg of my quick and dirty illustrations for comparison. I think that the long narrow object at the top of the structure is the paraphallus? anyway, it rides along the phallus on carnaria and flops over the distiphallus on variegata (pale red arrows on my second outline).

I hope that this helps and Best wishes,
John
johnes81 attached the following image:


[27.07Kb]
John and Nini. Naturalists not experts.
 
johnes81
#12 Print Post
Posted on 19-10-2019 10:16
User Avatar

Member

Location: Berlin, Germany
Posts: 1978
Joined: 15.10.16

illustration with arrows to the identifiable features
johnes81 attached the following image:


[27.96Kb]
John and Nini. Naturalists not experts.
 
Rui Andrade
#13 Print Post
Posted on 19-10-2019 12:44
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

Hi John,

Very nice illustrations, thank you for sharing them! If I'm not mistaken the arrows are pointing to a structure called juxta. The difference between the two species is very clear in your illustrations. Smile
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
johnes81
#14 Print Post
Posted on 19-10-2019 14:14
User Avatar

Member

Location: Berlin, Germany
Posts: 1978
Joined: 15.10.16

Rui Andrade wrote:Very nice illustrations, thank you for sharing them!


Hello Rui,

The illustrations are horrible to me. I've actually won awards for my pencil drawing skills, so i am not happy to post these awful outlines. I also own a pen tablet but i rarely use it. I don't have time to master digital drawing. However, i intend to use my pen tablet to illustrate genitalia in the future.

I also have microscopic photos of S, lehmani and haemorrhoa genitalia. Sarcs are easy to find even at my balcony and inside of my flat. I actually saved a Sarc from certain death because it was trapped in my bird feeder. I came outside at the right time because i am certain that slender-billed birds at my feeder would've grabbed it for a midday snack.

Anyway, someday i will illustrate the genitalia properly using my pentablet and specialized graphics software.

Best wishes,
John
John and Nini. Naturalists not experts.
 
Rui Andrade
#15 Print Post
Posted on 19-10-2019 21:54
User Avatar

Member

Location: Portugal
Posts: 3064
Joined: 19.06.07

Well, the illustrations were very useful, so I'm looking forward to see the ones made with more care!
 
www.flickr.com/photos/rui_andrade/
Daniel Whitmore
#16 Print Post
Posted on 07-05-2020 15:06
Member

Location: Stuttgart, Germany
Posts: 69
Joined: 09.07.10

Interesting thread. Rui's fly from Porto certainly looks like variegata. The vesica is indeed larger than it generally is, but this feature can vary somewhat in this group of species.

Nice illustrations John! You have labelled one as carnaria and one as variegata, but in my opinion both are carnaria.

Pape (1987) and Richet et al. (2011) are excellent references, but I also think Chris Raper's side-by-side photos actually show the differences between the three British species quite nicely.

I recently created a Facebook group about British Sarcophagidae (https://www.facebook.com/groups/459564384954251/) in case anyone is interested. Just yesterday I posted a couplet with annotated photos distinguishing males of S. carnaria and S. variegata, which I attach also here. Other characters can also be used to distinguish the two species, but I think these work quite well.

EDIT: the file is too large to attach, you can find it in the Facebook group or PM me and I'll email it to you if interested.
Edited by Daniel Whitmore on 07-05-2020 15:08
Daniel
 
Jump to Forum:
Similar Threads
Thread Forum Replies Last Post
Sarcophagidae > Sarcophaga Diptera (adults) 5 01-12-2020 21:12
Sarcophaga sp. or more? Diptera (adults) 1 18-11-2020 13:56
Sarcophagidae? -> Sarcophaga Diptera (adults) 6 06-11-2020 16:12
which Sarcophaga? Diptera (adults) 1 08-10-2020 20:00
Sarcophaga cf. carnaria << Sarcophagidae ID Diptera (adults) 3 08-10-2020 13:12
Date and time
05 December 2020 18:48
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Temporary email?
Due to fact this site has functionality making use of your email address, any registration using a temporary email address will be rejected.

Paul
Donate
Please, help to make
Diptera.info
possible and enable
further improvements!
Latest Articles
Syrph the Net
Those who want to have access to the Syrph the Net database need to sign the
License Agreement -
Click to Download


Public files of Syrph the Net can be downloaded HERE

Last updated: 25.08.2011
Shoutbox
You must login to post a message.

28.11.20 19:50
Never letting them to dry too quickly before Grin?

24.11.20 16:44
Anybody knows how to avoid compound eyes invaginating when drying and how to restore them?

13.10.20 16:16
You can edit your own thread - button "Edit" below.

12.10.20 12:24
Can I edit a thread subject?

28.09.20 06:58
Use “new thread” buttom right below

26.09.20 16:56
How do I post ? Smile

28.08.20 11:57
That woul be up to me, as an administrator. Smile

27.08.20 11:30
I want to move a thread to the Syphridae subforum - how can I do this?

24.08.20 12:17
How do I post?

08.08.20 13:31
ah ok ! I didn't knew oops !

Render time: 5.30 seconds | 148,354,745 unique visits