Diptera.info :: Family forums :: Syrphidae
Who is here? 1 guest(s)
 Platycheirus male (nielseni?)
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 20-08-2010 21:23
|
 Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Hi, The only one I can find which has a front tarsus swelling like this is Platycheirus amplus. It certainly is ample! But it seems this species has only been found in Scotland so far, and with very few records at that. I can't find any pics of P. amplus, but it is supposed to resemble P. peltatus in the spots as one in historic records was mistaken for that. Help me please, I am going mad.  Taken in my garden south of Lincoln UK on 16th August. I am in a woodlands and heathlands type location, it was feeding on Veronica which is near my pond and not far from a roadside drain. I have two pics, posting a third crop of the front end. Janet 
blowave attached the following image:  [108.63Kb] Edited by blowave on 22-08-2010 22:53 http://cubits.org... |
 |
|
| blowave |
Posted on 20-08-2010 21:24
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
pic 2
blowave attached the following image:  [114.5Kb] http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 20-08-2010 21:24
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
pic 3
blowave attached the following image:  [126.95Kb] http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| Gerard Pennards |
Posted on 21-08-2010 21:51
|
 Member Location: Amersfoort Posts: 1914 Joined: 07.06.04 |
Platycheirus peltatus male....
Greetings, Gerard Pennards |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 22-08-2010 01:38
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Oooh thanks Gerard, I had named one which looked similar P. peltatus but this one has such a large swelling on the tarsi...
http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 22-08-2010 22:51
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Gerard, I had at least one P. peltatus in my garden most of the day yesterday so I got a lot of pics. I wonder if you could look again at the shape of the swollen section of the tarsus. To me, the shape is quite different to what I see as peltatus. The bottom line of the swollen section in peltatus is a continuous curve, where on my fly it looks to curve upwards in a 'u' shape towards the point. There are other subtle differences too. As you thought the female Platycheirus I had could be P. nielseni, I wonder if this male could be too. I can't find anything at all about nielseni, not even a drawing of the tarsi. I now also see that P. amplus has a continuous line at the bottom of the swollen section, and a more blunted point. I was searching for P. neilseni and found an old thread here, where Andre had suggested either P. amplus or neilseni for a fly which looks to have the same shape tarsus as mine, I think! http://www.dipter...pid=119033 Once more I am thinking this is This pic is of P. peltatus I believe.. blowave attached the following image:  [181.86Kb] http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| Gerard Pennards |
Posted on 23-08-2010 09:04
|
|
Member Location: Amersfoort Posts: 1914 Joined: 07.06.04 |
Hey Janet, Well, I can tell you that peltatus and nielseni cannot be separated by using only the first leg. The explanation is simple: these first legs are identical! Identification between males of these species is made by looking at the shape and the hairs on tibia of the second leg. In nielseni the shape of this tibia is slightly different from peltatus. The assumption is generally made that peltatus is commom, whereas nielseni is rare in England. In sweden it's a different story, nielseni is more common and there are some other species of this group as well! Greetings, Greetings, Gerard Pennards |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 23-08-2010 13:43
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Thank you Gerard for that information! Now I think then that the first one cannot be P. nielseni, as the shape of the swollen section on the tarsus is different to the second fly which does fit P. peltatus (or nielseni) well. But as you say, nielseni is more rare. I do have flies in my location which are much rarer than P. nielseni though! Where does that leave us? 
http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 23-08-2010 20:38
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
I have a tibia #2 pic from the last fly From the drawing I have looked at of nielseni tibia 2, this looks like it could be that. It would make sense if I have a female which looks like nielseni too. Does the eye of experience think so too? picture didn't go in.. Edited by blowave on 23-08-2010 20:39 http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 23-08-2010 20:40
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
couldn't add the pic with an edit so trying again.. hmm, I see the pic flash up before my eyes but it doesn't show. Maybe I will try later. Trying again.. Edited by blowave on 24-08-2010 00:22 http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| Andre |
Posted on 24-08-2010 12:22
|
 Member Location: Tilburg, the Netherlands Posts: 2111 Joined: 18.07.04 |
Forget it.. we will not give you a waterproof ID of nielseni based on pictures. Well, not me, that is...  |
|
|
|
| conopid |
Posted on 24-08-2010 13:13
|
 Member Location: United Kingdom Posts: 1039 Joined: 02.07.04 |
These flies are hard enough to decipher with a specimen under the microscope, so as Andre' says the best thing to do is forget determining the species from a photo. That way it won't drive you mad any longer! It's always worth collecting specimens if you really must know the specific identity of a fly in the genus Platycheirus.
Nigel Jones, Shrewsbury, United Kingdom |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 24-08-2010 13:58
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Lol, that's about what I thought Andre. Nigel, I can't help but try to find what I have even if it drives me mad! I can't do the collecting thing though. At last while I'm looking I'm learning, and that can help with the more obvious ones.  Well I will still try to post my pic anyway, for the record! Here goes.. (it flashed before my eyes again, this was not meant to be! )I just realised, because I had a pic within size limits I had forgotten to rename it without capitals etc! blowave attached the following image:  [117.69Kb] Edited by blowave on 24-08-2010 14:03 http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| conopid |
Posted on 24-08-2010 15:31
|
|
Member Location: United Kingdom Posts: 1039 Joined: 02.07.04 |
Nope, I can't do it from that. You'll have to train them to pose with legs held out in the right positions Nigel Jones, Shrewsbury, United Kingdom |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 24-08-2010 16:18
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
conopid wrote: Nope, I can't do it from that. You'll have to train them to pose with legs held out in the right positions Oh, but can't you tell I have already done that? Description (and drawing) of P. nielseni tibia from Van Veen, I hope I'm not out of place putting this here but it does illustrate it well I think. Constriction on tibia 2 profound and about 1/3 the length of tibia, preceded by a swelling and ending in a strongly swollen apex, upper part of swollen apex with a tuft of longish hairs.... P. nielseni Description of P. peltatus.. Constriction on tibia 2 shallow and about half the length of tibia, preceded by a swelling and ending in weakly swollen apex, this apex only with short erect hairs;..... P. peltatus Pic of P. nielseni tibia drawing.. blowave attached the following image:  [14.38Kb] Edited by blowave on 24-08-2010 16:19 http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| Andre |
Posted on 27-08-2010 10:20
|
|
Member Location: Tilburg, the Netherlands Posts: 2111 Joined: 18.07.04 |
Maybe you have a P. nielseni there. |
|
|
|
| blowave |
Posted on 27-08-2010 15:20
|
|
Member Location: LINCOLN, UK Posts: 3151 Joined: 27.06.07 |
Andre wrote: Maybe you have a P. nielseni there. Thanks Andre, I thought (or still think) so too!
http://cubits.org... |
|
|
|
| Andre |
Posted on 29-08-2010 19:30
|
|
Member Location: Tilburg, the Netherlands Posts: 2111 Joined: 18.07.04 |
I only said maybe... |
|
|
|
| Jump to Forum: |