Thread subject: Diptera.info :: Volucella inanis?

Posted by PeterD on 09-09-2010 23:58
#1

Could anyone please confirm, or correct, my ID?

www.imageinuk.com/Other/Query-Support-Files/9096137/1001258337_LUhKj-M.jpg
Click here for larger image>> http://www.imagei...hKj-XL.jpg

www.imageinuk.com/Other/Query-Support-Files/9096135/1001256072_AfTuC-M.jpg
Click here for larger image>> http://www.imagei...TuC-XL.jpg

Thank you

Posted by ChrisR on 10-09-2010 00:07
#2

That looks correct to me :)

Posted by PeterD on 10-09-2010 02:51
#3

ChrisR wrote:
That looks correct to me :)


Thanks Chris;)

Posted by Andre on 10-09-2010 11:50
#4

No, this is Volucella zonaria. Compare with pics in the gallery.. the tip of the abdomen, for instance.

Edited by Andre on 10-09-2010 11:50

Posted by ChrisR on 10-09-2010 12:41
#5

I see your point (V.inanis should have more black bands near the tip of the abdomen) - that's the palest V.zonaria I have seen but maybe it was a trick of the flash/light?

Posted by Menno Reemer on 10-09-2010 12:58
#6

I vote for the original identification as V. inanis.
In V. zonaria, sternite 2 is black, while in V. inanis this is yellow. In this specimen it's clearly yellow. In addition, you can vaguely see a dark macula halfway the anterior part of the wing. Such a macula is never present in V. zonaria, but you'll find it in V. inanis.

Posted by ChrisR on 10-09-2010 13:06
#7

Yeah, I did rather wonder about the shading on the wing ... and this one doesn't seem to have any noticeable change in yellow colour between tergites 1+2 and the rest.

Posted by Andre on 10-09-2010 14:06
#8

All true!
I quit ID'ing from pics $##%!^****$#@@#!!@!
:|

Posted by PeterD on 10-09-2010 14:27
#9

Thank you all for this very interesting debate. I have seen a number of V. inanis this summer and in particular in the last month. When I saw this one I thought it a little odd in its basic colouration. Although I am aware of the number of Volucella species in the UK I did think this one was worth posting with what I considered the closest ID.
Trying to ID from photographs can be challenging so I appreciate help when I am not sure.

;)