Gallery Links
Users Online
· Guests Online: 7

· Members Online: 0

· Total Members: 3,973
· Newest Member: Audrey
Forum Threads
Theme Switcher
Switch to:
Last Seen Users
· bgmot00:12:51
· usiaz01:29:16
· Juergen Peters03:58:04
· John Carr04:45:45
· piros05:39:17
· Tony Irwin06:01:49
· Quaedfliegh06:08:35
· Rumpelstiltskin06:25:21
· Carnifex06:40:21
· PhilC06:48:12
Latest Photo Additions
View Thread
Diptera.info :: Miscellaneous :: General queries
Who is here? 1 guest(s)
 Print Thread
Dutch Parallelomma species
nielsyese
#1 Print Post
Posted on 07-12-2017 16:38
User Avatar

Member

Location: Netherlands
Posts: 1941
Joined: 13.02.09

Hi everybody,
I'm struggling with the taxonomy of the two Dutch Parallelomma species. When I look in the checklist by Beuk, I can see two species:

* Parallelomma media Becker, 1894
* Parallelomma vittata (Meigen, 1826)

When I look in the key from Ball (2007), Key to the British Scathophagidae (Diptera), two species are mentioned:
* Parallelomma paridis Hering, 1923
* Parallelomma vittatum (Meigen, 1826)

Of course it might be possible that paridis is another species that occurs in Britain, but not in the Netherlands, so I was also checking www.bladmineerders.nl. This is a website about all mining flies in the Netherlands. They mention two species: Americina vittata and Americina media. But when I look for the synonyms of Americina vittata, I find:

Chylizosoma vittatum; Parallelomma paridis (Hering, 1923); P. convallariae (Kaltenbach, 1873); P. beckeri Séguy, 1932; P. paucheti Séguy, 1932; P. hostae Hering, 1955; P. sasakawae Hering, 1955; P. albamentum Séguy, 1963.

So: we have a species called Americina vittata synonym with Parallelomma paridis, which is in the key from Ball together with Parallelomma vittatum. I think this is really strange!!

Can somebody clarify this issue for me?Smile
Best wishes, Niels-Jan Dek
 
nielsyese
#2 Print Post
Posted on 11-12-2017 21:42
User Avatar

Member

Location: Netherlands
Posts: 1941
Joined: 13.02.09

Any ideas about this question?
Best wishes, Niels-Jan Dek
 
Steve Crellin
#3 Print Post
Posted on 12-12-2017 12:42
Member

Location: Isle of Man
Posts: 41
Joined: 01.09.04

I don't know if this will help or note but this is the note on Parallelomma in the British checklist.
http://www.dipteristsforum.org.uk/documents/BRITISH_ISLES_CHECKLIST.pdf page 369.

"1. Parallelomma paridis Hering, 1923 was synonymised with vittatum by Šifner (1978), but reinstated by Nelson (1990). Šifner
(1995, 2008) reaffirmed this synonymy, which had not been accepted by Gorodkov (1986), but Nelson's view is accepted here."

I think it comes down to whether you follow Sifner's view that there is only one species or Nelson/Gorodkov that there are two species of Paralleloma.
Steve Crellin
steve_crellin1@hotmail.co.uk
Isle of Man
 
Paul Beuk
#4 Print Post
Posted on 12-12-2017 14:00
User Avatar

Super Administrator

Location: Netherlands
Posts: 16107
Joined: 11.05.04

I do not have Nelson's papers on Scathophagidae so I could not comment. There is a similar 'crisis' with some of the Scathophaga species with unclarity which names belong with two species.

Part of my correspondence with MArco Bernaconi:
Before the molecular [by Bernasconi et al.] work there were also two different interpretations dealing with these two species:
S. suilla (=S. taeniopa) and S. ordinata [Sifner, 1975, 1995]
S. suilla and S. taeniopa (=S. ordinata) [Gorodkov, 1986]

Sifner (2008) decided to accept the name taeniopa after all and he refers to Gorodkov's list of 1986: "Synonymized by GORODKOV (1986: 34)". However, I think he made an error in accepting that Gorodkov's listing in the catalogue as synonymization. Gorodkov used the name taeniopa earlier for a valid species (Insects of Mongolia, not available to me). At the same time he may not have been aware of ordinata as separate species or already accepting that as synonym of taeniopa. In either case, Sifner formally synonymized suilla and taeniopa in 1975 and my assumption is that Gorodkov, whilst preparing the 1986 catalogue, was not aware of it or chose to ignore it since he does not state a reference where the synonymization by Sifner is refuted.
For the name taeniopa to become available again it should have been resurrected from synonymy or someone should have stated in no uncertain terms that Sifner was wrong to synonymize these species in 1975. As far as I know, neither was done and, in my view, Gorodkov, 1986 does not do it either.

So [...] how it came to be that the name taeniopa was used [in the molecular works]. I assume it can be traced back to the keys used for identification of the species. Are you aware which keys were used to identify the species in the molecular work?

Perhaps a bit academic but it seems a valid question nevertheless since no-one seems to have examined the type of taeniopa to see with which species it actually agrees...

Paul

- - - -

Paul Beuk on https://diptera.info
 
https://diptera.info
Jump to Forum:
Similar Threads
Thread Forum Replies Last Post
Parallelomma media ? (NL) Diptera (adults) 1 10-05-2018 17:19
Looks like a male Eristalinus sp. but what species? Syrphidae 2 27-04-2018 22:49
Fly species Diptera (adults) 10 14-04-2018 16:02
A Phoridae species Diptera (adults) 5 08-04-2018 19:02
Anthomyiidae? => Delia species Diptera (adults) 3 05-03-2018 06:26
Date and time
25 May 2018 06:59
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Temporary email?
Due to fact this site has functionality making use of your email address, any registration using a temporary email address will be rejected.

Paul
Donate
Please, help to make
Diptera.info
possible and enable
further improvements!
Latest Articles
Syrph the Net
Those who want to have access to the Syrph the Net database need to sign the
License Agreement -
Click to Download


Public files of Syrph the Net can be downloaded HERE

Last updated: 25.08.2011
Shoutbox
You must login to post a message.

21.05.18 23:44
Hello friends, I've heard from Stephane today and he is safe and sound. Very good news!

21.05.18 12:23
Thanks very much

19.05.18 22:27
z.gr.T: zum großen/größten Teil. You should purchase a copy of Duden Das Wörterbuch der Abkürzungen.

19.05.18 12:20
No-one knows where Stephane is, we all hope he is well...

19.05.18 12:19
Hello Can any1 help with the meaning of an abbrev. Rebberge (Muscarl-Alllelum Hüg. 56 z. gr. T.) z.gr.T - thx

17.05.18 01:21
Where is Stéphane Lebrun? I strongly miss his expertise in Muscidae Frown. I hope, he is doing well these days. Jürgen

09.05.18 13:38
Thanks Tony

08.05.18 21:47
Katalog der paläarktischen Dipteren

08.05.18 11:20
Hello Can any1 help out with thye full title of Kat. Pal. Dipt. Thanks

03.05.18 22:05
Next week I hope to have time again to ID Anthomyiidae......
.. Johanna

Render time: 1.50 seconds | 134,262,885 unique visits